[19:10] -irc.weresource.org- *** Looking up your hostname... [19:10] -irc.weresource.org- *** Found your hostname [19:10] * STDCLogger (PircBot@WS239FFA-B663F2CE.org) has joined #stdc [19:10] * Topic is 'Welcome to the Serious Therianthropy Discussion Chat. Logged chats are the second and fourth Sunday monthy, 7PM Eastern. If you have any questions, please ask someone with ops (@). NEXT STDC 5/10 @ 7PM Eastern (4 PM Pacific)' [19:10] * Set by TerrorWolf on Sun May 10 11:52:53 GMT-04:00 2009 [19:10] Welcome everybody and thank you for coming tonight! [19:10] * WolfFriend sets mode +h STDCLogger [19:10] The channel will be moderated while we explain the rules. [19:10] ::: RULES ::: [19:10] If you have any questions, please ask WolfFriend or myself [19:10] Please do not spam the channel with off-topic stuff -- Take it to PM [19:11] Please do not spam the channel with off-topic stuff -- Take it to PM [19:11] When we introduce the topic at the start, we will be voicing/unvoicing participants so they may give cursorary discussions on the topic [19:11] If you would like to speak, please PM myself or WolfFriend and we will voice you so you may say your part [19:11] After we have detailed the conversation enough, it iwll be open for a full discussion [19:11] The reason we do the cursoary is so that any sub-topics of that topic can be raised, and addressed [19:11] Does anyone have any questions? [19:11] * TerrorWolf sets mode -m [19:12] No [19:12] how do you PM from here again? [19:12] Nope. (Bawww, I gotta go, I have to be up in five hours for school. D: See you guys! x) [19:12] i do but they are ecumenical in nature and not related to chan topic ^>.>^ [19:12] moonwolf: Either /query name or double click on theri name [19:12] moonwolf: You should be able to double-click the name on the userlist [19:12] It will open a new tab or window and you can type there [19:12] I.. need to go to bed. Good night, also. [19:12] Anyone else? [19:12] Thanks [19:12] depends on your client. Mine does not do that. [19:12] * TerrorWolf sets mode +m [19:12] Ok [19:13] Many therians have described (what they call) totemic experiences or spirit guides. Do you feel that this is related to therianthropy at all? What about those that are non-therians but have a very close bond to their totem or spirit guide that may resemble therianthropy--when is it not? [19:13] If that fails, type /msg username (message here) [19:13] * TerrorWolf sets mode +v Buffalo [19:13] * SilverTiger (95fe315d@WS239FFA-2C33FAE9.mibbit.com) Quit (Quit: http://www.mibbit.com ajax IRC Client) [19:13] For me totemism and therianthropy do not overlap. I was given my totem by having bison appearing behind my eyelids every time I closed them in my spiritual support group, then being channeled to in a language that turned out to be Lakota. I have never tried on the body of a bison, let alone feeling myself to somehow actually be one. [19:13] I felt wings but was able to remove and ignore them. [19:13] * Amourosa (81dbbfb1@WS239FFA-2C33FAE9.mibbit.com) has joined #stdc [19:14] So I do not consider myself a therian. [19:14] Queue: Bearcat [19:14] Thank you for the chance to speak. Done. [19:14] Thank you. [19:14] Bearcat is up next [19:14] * WolfFriend sets mode -v+v Buffalo Bearcat [19:14] er..buffalo you need to talk longer so i can gather my thoughts and look smart. [19:15] Should I return the talking stick? [19:15] no, i'm still chewing on it. I'll be fine. [19:15] Ok [19:15] for me they overlap. [19:15] Queue: TigerAcolyte [19:15] * Oblivian (55e39fb3@WS239FFA-2C33FAE9.mibbit.com) Quit (Quit: http://www.mibbit.com ajax IRC Client) [19:16] In my case, my inner vision and sense of self may be the same as i lived in another life. I'm still trying to determine what is "real" and what is not about all that. [19:17] My guides look like similar beings to myself one more wolf-like another catlike as i am. [19:17] i also have what may be memories of interacting with them as physical beings somehow/somewhere. [19:18] Queue: TigerAcolyte, GhiaDon [19:19] totemicly i have difficulty with the concept. Most of or modern ideas on totemism, are very modern. Usually one's clan would have a guiding animal spirtit or one's tribe. It was not an individual thing. This idea of individual totems seems to be an idea that has poped up an taken hold in the last 40 years or so. [19:20] be that as it may, people can often feel strong influences from totemic animals which may be confused for therianthopy. My general take on it is that thereianthropy is *internal* whereas a totemic influence is *external*. For people that are new to either idea that can be hard to explain and feel out. [19:21] Many get confused by that and feel themselves to be therianthropes when they are infact just heavily influenced by a totem, or visa-versa. [19:21] so it's a connected idea, just like Furry is. [19:22] i feel like im rambling now. [19:22] Hands the chewed on stick to WolfFriend. "There i left some cat-spit on there for you to give it extra flavor!" [19:22] Hehe [19:22] Thank you [19:22] anytime [19:22] Next up is TigerAcolyte [19:23] you want more just ask [19:23] * WolfFriend nods [19:23] * WolfFriend sets mode -v+v Bearcat TigerAcolyte [19:23] Queue: GhiaDon [19:23] In my opinion, Therianthropy, taken as a whole, [19:23] (Oh gosh, cut + paste doesn't work >_< ) [19:24] *One moment please* [19:25] has little to do with totemic experiences and/or spirit guides. [19:26] However, this does not mean the two areas cannot overlap. I will not go into how they can overlap, as the possibilities are endless. [19:26] Instead, I will explain how I see the two subjects as naturally unrelated. [19:26] There is a fine line between being one with a spirit guide and being "yourself." [19:27] Both can be on and off experiences, but only one can vanish from your life without some sort of consequence. [19:27] A spirit guide and/or totem can change over time. [19:28] In fact, from what I've read about the subject consistently among several sources, [19:28] totems come and go as they see fit "for you." [19:28] They are also meant to give you power to learn and grow off of--they have a definite purpose for being in your life. [19:29] Therianthropy, however, does not necessarily have a purpose for being part of an individual. [19:29] One's therian essence cannot "leave" without there being some sort of consequence illustrated over time. [19:29] I quote "leave" because that's what someone might just as well call it. [19:30] However, by "leave", I actually mean lock-up in the deepest reaches of the mind where direct influence, [19:30] from the therian component, over one's life is limited. [19:31] Nevertheless, it will still affect the individual's life through this limited influence it still retains, hence the long time it would take for [19:31] back-lash to build up to any appreciable level. [19:31] The opposite is true with spirit-guides/totems. *Cuts off thoughts* [19:31] I am done. [19:31] * TerrorWolf sets mode -v+v TigerAcolyte GhiaDon [19:31] * graylocke (graylocke@WS239FFA-10347DF9.static.internode.on.net) has joined #stdc [19:31] Thank you TigerAcolyte [19:33] GhiaDon is up [19:34] I can say from my own experience that I do not believe that therianthropy and guides/totems have much in relation, if any relation at all. [19:35] I do not have a guide or totem myself, and neither did I have one in my past. But I am a therian none the less. [19:37] There seems to be many therians who do have one, or several, or many, and I think (not know, this is just my hypothesis) is that being a therian makes you more open to things, like your spiritual side, and you are more welcoming to see and explore, therefore you have a better chance of identifying guides. [19:38] But if you do not have one, then you just do not see it, however open you may be. It does not disclude me being a therian because I do not have a guide, so I do not think that there is a relation between the two. [19:38] That's all I have to add, with everyone else's comments. [19:38] Thank you [19:38] If there is no one else who would like to give their thoughts, we will go into open discussion. [19:39] * TerrorWolf sets mode -m [19:39] * WolfFriend sets mode -v GhiaDon [19:39] Everyone can speak now :) [19:39] *mew*? [19:39] :p [19:40] well...i don't quite know what to say. I think we're all on the same page here, yeah? [19:40] I believe so. [19:40] *nods* So it seems. [19:40] From who has spoken, yes :P [19:40] UYes [19:40] Has anyone ever done a "journey" or whatever to find a spirit guide and simply not found one? [19:40] I have heard one say that it seems that therians do have a tendency to pick up "spirit guides" [19:40] * Shonsu yips [19:40] wooo! [19:40] Shonsu :P [19:41] WolfFriend: ahh, so there is one among us whom is not to be trusted!? I knew it!! It's terrorwolf, isn't it [19:41] * Shonsu was away fromkeyboard dancing to feelgood music [19:41] lol WolfFriend [19:41] err [19:41] ... [19:41] ha ha [19:41] lol Bearcat [19:41] Depends on what you mean as "journey"? [19:41] ;) [19:41] I have not done a journey to seek out a spirit guide [19:41] WolfFriend: you get more cat-like every day. Keep it up. There is hope for you yet. [19:41] :P [19:41] Like a special meditation or something, at least made a credible, legit effort to find one [19:41] I *have* journeyed otherwise. I have interacted with spirits. But I am not in any formal "guide" relationship with any. [19:42] Amourosa: that's an interesting question. I'd tend to trust a result wherein i did not find one than when i did. [19:42] I didn't find too many of my guides through a specific meditation. Quite a few of them, but some of them just.. occured to me, if you will. <.< [19:42] Being a Christian, the Holy Spirit is my primary spirit guide, as it is :P [19:42] Ah, no, I haven't with the specific intention of finding a guide. [19:42] I have led such a journey. A short one with novices but most people seemed to find a guide. [19:42] mm [19:42] WolfFriend: what is the difference between the Holy Spirit and the HGA? [19:42] HGA? [19:43] Well, I ask because I talk to people who say, "I don't have a spirit guide" or "not everyone has a spirit guide" or a similar relationship with a spiritual entity . . . and then I ask if they've ever looked and they say, "No." [19:43] Holy Guardian Angel the Crowlien expression of the Inner-higher self [19:43] So . . . [19:43] Ah. I don't know much about that entity. [19:43] * Shonsu has to admit that he does not understand totems and for all he knows has never had a spirit guide [19:43] Aleister Crowley FTW [19:43] The Holy Spirit is one of the persons of the triune God. [19:43] So it is God. [19:43] I mean, my spirit guide was with me before I started working with her [19:44] So, just because I wasn't working with her doesn't mean she wasn't there, I still had a guide [19:44] Could one have a totem or spirit guide that is the same as one's therioside? And how would you know? [19:44] as lame as it sounds, one of mine have been around since i was four. [19:44] Yeah, mine's a white wolf [19:44] * SerpentineZebra has nothing really to say about totems or spirit guides except a feeling that I have one of each [19:44] That is the same? [19:44] moonwolf: if you met a wolf, would you be able to tell the difference between it and yourself? [19:44] *loves Serase* [19:44] moonwolf, I think that in that situation, it may be a question of is it you or not you? [19:44] Ah, like Bearcat said [19:45] mmm [19:45] good statement BC [19:45] I see. [19:45] thank you [19:45] moonwolf: By the way, did you get my PM? [19:45] Yeah, good one BC [19:45] I think I have a zebra as a spirit guide (though it acts more like a muse than anything), and lately, it seems, a wasp as a shadow totem [19:45] I suppose it is the perspective. I don't view myself in the third person. [19:45] Interestingly I seemed to have my grandmother as a spirit guide until I became aware of her, then she moved on. [19:45] GhiaDon: what is the same? [19:45] That's cool, Buffalo [19:45] :) [19:46] Buffalo: I got a really funny image from that, but that is pretty awesome [19:46] i asked one of my guides once "How do i know you are real?" He asked me if he had given me good advice, shown me love and guided me well. I said "yes." He said "if i am not real then it was *you* doing those things. Isn't that even better?" [19:46] maybe you'll become a spirit guide for your offspring :p [19:46] No WolfFriend, I didn't get a PM [19:46] moonwolf, it should show up as a tab on the top of your screen? [19:46] or on the bottom, actually [19:46] WolfFriend: mine show up on the top . . . [19:46] Amourosa, depends on the client :P [19:47] WolfFriend: Ohhh, okay! :D [19:47] Amourosa, I don't understand your question. [19:47] GhiaDon: above you asked "That is the same?" I was asking you to clarify what "that" was. [19:47] Maybe so WF, it seems I have a psychic bond with my grandson already. [19:47] Neither at top nor bottom???? [19:48] Ah, I was responding to your question on if one could have a therioside and guide that was similiar and didn't know it? That's what I thought you asked. [19:48] * WolfFriend (Ben@wsserv.weresource.org) Quit (Connection reset by peer) [19:48] i didn't do it!! [19:48] Oh, no I was saying that a, say, wolf therian could also have a Wolf totem/spirit guide. [19:48] YES YOU DID!!! [19:48] >.> [19:48] * WolfFriend (Ben@wsserv.weresource.org) has joined #stdc [19:48] * ChanServ sets mode +o WolfFriend [19:48] nuh-uh! [19:49] wolfriend did it! [19:49] GhiaDon: did that help? (my reply above) [19:49] er..hi WolfFriend [19:49] :o [19:49] :P [19:49] Hehe [19:49] WolfFriend: how COULD YOU@?@ [19:49] Bearcat: I saw what you said via tha logger window :P [19:49] * Bearcat *licks a paw and looks the innocent cat he is* [19:49] Amourosa, I see now, I think my replies when off track. You can disregard them if you like, haha. [19:50] moonwolf: There should be a button or a tab under the chat area with my name on it? [19:51] I see it [19:51] GhiaDon: what does your username mean? Or the significance of it, I guess? [19:51] that is my PM window, moonwolf [19:51] Amourosa: No significance, Karmann Ghia was my favorite car, Don is my name. [19:52] do I click it or something WolfFriend? [19:52] There, 2nd topic is replied to. ^^ I'm a happy kitty [19:52] Yup, moonwolf. [19:52] You click it and you can see my PM [19:52] cool [19:52] Then to get back you click on #weresource [19:52] err [19:52] #stdc [19:52] Amourosa: Your name have any special meaning? [19:52] OK will do [19:52] * Bearcat listens to Porcupine Tree [19:52] GhiaDon: cool, hold on [19:52] Are we ready for the next topic? [19:52] * Shonsu listens to Animal Collective [19:52] YES!!! [19:52] Aye [19:52] porcupine tree. <3 [19:52] * TerrorWolf sets mode +m [19:53] Many therians desire to be open about their therianthropy with others, but for many people, it is something that is very weird and therefore can lead to misunderstanding and (especially for minors) parents trying to keep their kids away from the therianthropy community because they feel it to be a bad influence. However, many have also had great successes in being open about their therianthropy to others. What kinds of concerns do you face if you want [19:53] Cut off [19:53] oh [19:53] What kinds of concerns do you face if you want to share your feelings with your loved ones and friends? If you had success in doing so, what worked for you, or what didn't work for you? [19:54] Bearcat is up first [19:54] * WolfFriend sets mode +v Bearcat [19:54] i was just saying "but i dont' want to go first I'm just gathering my thoughts" [19:54] heh [19:54] can i go second? [19:54] Sure [19:54] * TerrorWolf sets mode -v+v Bearcat Shonsu [19:54] Shonsu will be up then [19:54] woo! [19:54] Queue: Bearcat [19:54] thank you BC :) [19:55] The topic is very correct in reffering to therianthropy as "weird" and that is the very reason that I have trouble talking to my friends and family about it [19:55] Queue: Bearcat, WolfFriend [19:56] in fact, I believe that one of the specific reasons I have trouble talking about is because it is so weird that I myself havent even fully accepted it yet [19:57] personally I fear talking to friends and family about it because i am convinced that they will all either have negative reactions about it or simply brush it off as a joke [19:57] that would not be good for my current process of accepting it myself' [19:57] Queue: Bearcat, TigerAcolyte, WolfFriend, Nessbeast [19:57] I have a secret fear that my mother can convince me that everything I believe in is a self generated lie [19:58] however there have been a few people I have told [19:58] I think that it is wise to consider who you tell [19:58] it is not something that is easily approachable (for me at least) but it is not impossible [19:59] im done for now [19:59] thank you! [19:59] Thank you :) [19:59] * TerrorWolf sets mode -v+v Shonsu Bearcat [19:59] Next up is Bearcat [19:59] Queue: TigerAcolyte, WolfFriend, Nessbeast, GhiaDon [20:00] mew? [20:00] is this thing on? [20:00] no :-P [20:00] oh, [20:00] er..something jumps out at me there shonsu, but it's not directed at you specificly [20:01] if you are afraid to tell someone because you fear they may convonce you out of it, perhaps you are afraid of a truth. [20:01] i could talk about this for hours but i'll try to coalesce my thoughts [20:03] there are three things that make me "wierd" that i don't tell everyone, in order of what may make them the most uneasy and make my life difficult to be exposed. 1) my sexuality (bi/omnisexual), my therianthropy and the fact that i am polyamourus and have two mates/lovers. [20:03] (a triad) [20:05] i tend to treat the first two the same. I don't tell everyone that i am a omisexual therianthrope, but i don't *hide* it either. If someone is making prejoritive comments about gays i will step up. I don't tell everyone that i have a cat-soul, but many many people have looked at me (strangers mostly) and said things like "are you some sort of cat-person"?). I did fully disclose all three to a co-worker whom is my only [20:05] confidant in this small somewhat-hick town [20:06] my relationships are a secret really. In fact none of you would know had that cat not been let out of the bag (so to speak) [20:06] but usually when i tell people about my therianthropy i am told "yeah, i knew that" or "yeah, you have always seemed like a cat to me anyway." [20:07] my parents said that same thing to me. "yes, dear i always knew you were a cat. Pas me the salt will you?" [20:07] i'm really off topic today, i apologise. [20:08] I think you are relatively on topic. [20:08] in reality, i think it's not that strange or a big deal. I've been aware of it since i was 6 and it always seemed 'normal' to me. [20:08] so because i am relaxed about it, others are too when i tell them. [20:08] hell, my name is Bearcat MoonWind Sandor, and my company is Feline Soul Systems. [20:08] hiding it? Not much. [20:09] i think that if it is someone whom you are worried about how they will take it, beacuase they are close to you then it is worth examining that realationship more clostley. [20:09] i couldn't bear to hide what i am from anyone let alone my clostest loved ones. [20:09] i'm too honest. [20:10] also, when i tell some one especially someone who may be skeptical and who has no idea what i am talking about, i get some of the best questions to go back and grill myself with. [20:10] That alone makes it all worth it. [20:10] There is more but i'm passing this bone to Wolffriend. [20:11] thanks [20:11] Thank you :) [20:11] Next up is TigerAcolyte [20:11] * WolfFriend sets mode -v+v Bearcat TigerAcolyte [20:11] Queue: WolfFriend, Nessbeast, GhiaDon [20:11] Being one who had problems with their therian component a few years before [20:12] even finding to be called Therianthropy, it wasn't all that difficult to share what was going on inside of me with others. [20:12] I say it wasn't difficult because there was no possibility of being linked to what an average person might [20:12] construe as a genre of people too lost in their own fantasies, or simply linked to a "silly" label. [20:13] What made it easier to share with others was that my strong interest in tigers was already well-known to those who knew me. [20:14] Also, I so deeply cared, and still do care, for tigers (and so myself as well) so much, that I didn't care if [20:14] someone thought of me as "being ridiculous" when I told them. [20:14] Tigers were/are far more important to me than any one's opinion, as thick headed as it sounds. [20:15] Granted, I didn't make a point of telling everyone of what was going on inside of me, [20:15] but I did speak of it to those that would be indirectly affected by its ever-growing impact on the way I lived. [20:15] Trying to keep it hidden from those I spent most of my time around, for fear of having action taken against me, generally [20:16] just kept my stress level way too high, which is what drove me to finally fill those individuals in on what I was. [20:17] I had already concluded many times in my mind that my soul was within 5% of a tiger's long before the symptoms of a surfacing therioside occurred. [20:17] * Loki (4c147fa4@WS239FFA-2C33FAE9.mibbit.com) has joined #stdc [20:17] However, ultimately, I found the easiest way to convey seriousness and sincerity over my therianthropy was to write out what was going on inside of me, [20:18] proof read it, make sure I had said everything I wanted to say about it, make sure it sounded at least somewhat believible, [20:19] then keep a relaxed, but serious expression after handing it to whoever I so wished to "enlighten". [20:19] * Loki (4c147fa4@WS239FFA-2C33FAE9.mibbit.com) Quit (Quit: http://www.mibbit.com ajax IRC Client) [20:19] * Loki (4c147fa4@WS239FFA-2C33FAE9.mibbit.com) has joined #stdc [20:20] My advice: don't speak of it in anything short of a stern, serious-yet-relaxed, and resolute voice, or else the other person might begin to think you're not being truthful [20:20] No matter what their reaction, take things calmly, and politely excuse yourself if you find that you are unable to proceed with a calm/relaxed, yet serious [20:21] approach. [20:21] * Lerangfang (Lerangfang@WS239FFA-5A8DD3B4.eastlink.ca) has joined #stdc [20:22] * TerrorWolf sets mode -v+v TigerAcolyte WolfFriend [20:22] Thank you, I hope that TigerAcolyte was finished? [20:23] * TerrorWolf sets mode +v TigerAcolyte [20:23] brushed or lightly delved into the subject, closer/deeper and deeper each time. [20:23] Though it wasn't on purpose, I do think that helps to get the person more receptive to the idea over [20:24] time. That way, when one does open up all out, they know this isn't just something coming out of the blue. [20:24] Much more I'd love to say, but I've said enough [20:24] I'm done [20:24] * TerrorWolf sets mode -v TigerAcolyte [20:25] Thank you :) [20:26] Ok [20:26] TigerAcolyte, you will have to later go over some of what you said, I think you got cut off [20:26] But for the interest of time we'll keep things moving here [20:26] For me [20:27] I have been very hidden about my thoughts, my therianthropy, and related issues for years [20:27] Even to my parents. I would be very closed off. [20:27] But, eventually, like TigerAcolyte said, the stress was mounting, and I needed to tell my folks. I am also very open with them and I don't like to lie. So it was another reason for me to come out. [20:28] I had been thinking about it for over a year, as this is obviously a difficult subject to broach. [20:28] When I worked up the courage, I had a plan. I talked about my feelings, and my evolution of these feelings over the years. I sent it in an email (writing is good for getting all your feelings out in an organized way anyway) [20:28] I didn't mention terms or the community at all in it. Just what I felt and experienced. [20:29] It went very well for me. My parents were accepting, and intrigued, as well as happy that I felt comfortable telling them my deepest thoughts, as they put it. [20:29] I still have yet to talk to them about it in person (that comes after I finish school here), but it went really well. [20:30] I later on the phone talked about the community and terms, but I found that information ancillary and not really important, as it is what I feel that matters in this kind of thing. [20:31] I think though, that my method of doing it this way helped reduce liklihood of them thinking I latched onto some group fad or the like. I think going into it saying "therianthropy" and "see, that's what this person said about it" is the wrong approach (at least it was for me), as it seems that's one way many people start thinking that you are latching onto a fad [20:31] You gain credibility too by explaining things yourself with your own words. Because it shows that you own these feelings and know what you are experiencing, and that it is real to you. [20:31] That is my opinion. [20:32] I think I will finish her, and pass on the talking stick. [20:32] * Tobisaurus (meow@WS239FFA-3908F2E4.cvx1-c.lee.dial.ntli.net) has joined #stdc [20:32] Next up is Nessbeast [20:32] * WolfFriend sets mode -v+v WolfFriend Nessbeast [20:32] whoo. :D okay. so. my turn. [20:32] On the first subject, I'm.. not really the sort of person who would fear really.. showing off parts of m yself [20:33] Queue: GhiaDon, Lerangfang [20:33] at all, though I can understand why some people would want to hold onto their secrets. Especially for people who are pack/familially oriented, and especially for therians whose animals are, the fear of rejection is very real and probably justified. Most often, the people I tell respond with O_o expressions, though I tend to surround myself with people who take me as weird anyway. [20:34] i think the worst result *I* ever got was someone scoffing at me and sayng to stop playing around with my fantasy world. :/ I try not to let too many things on that end bother me. There are lots of people I haven't told, and probably never will. [20:35] my family, for instance. Most of my friends. being a therian is something I'm actually very private about, I think you people are the first I've discussed it with outside the company of very few friends. I have found, howeve, what works for me [20:36] * graylocke (graylocke@WS239FFA-10347DF9.static.internode.on.net) has left #stdc [20:36] both in admitting therianism and also in admitting other fringe-culture thngs I'm involvd with-- attempting to gage the persons you're around. For instance, there are some people I know who scoff at religion or at paganism, and around them, I probably would be less inclined to mention, for instance, that I am neoshamanic, and definately that I feel non-human at best. [20:36] I just try toget a feel for people, and if they're open-minded about things, especially spiritual things, only THEN will i risk telling them anything on that subjecgt at all. [20:37] sorry if that was like.. not collected or on topic very much. it sounded a lot better in my head. [20:37] a looooot better [20:37] done. [20:37] <.< [20:37] Thank you :) [20:37] * TerrorWolf sets mode -v+v Nessbeast GhiaDon [20:37] * moonwolf (moonwolf@WS239FFA-65405AC0.dyn.centurytel.net) Quit (Quit: moonwolf) [20:37] Ah, thank you. [20:39] I agree with wolffriend entirely about not using the community as an example when you tell people about yourself, as it leads them to think that some external influence has convinced you that you feel/experience certain things. [20:42] I have told a few friends about myself, though in indirect truths that they are easier to understand. I will usually say that "I feel more like a rabbit than a person", it is not entirely the truth but if the person isn't able to relate to the entire truth then a partial is acceptable, at least to me. [20:42] * moonwolf (moonwolf@WS239FFA-65405AC0.dyn.centurytel.net) has joined #stdc [20:43] I prefer to have partial understanding as compared to no understanding. If later on they show interest and ask me questions, I will clarify and tell them more. [20:44] Now, this is probably an easier explaination because my therioside has been domesticated, and people can and do have close relationships with them, so they may interpret it as "you just really like them" or "you feel so close to them that you can relate to them". [20:45] So, I do not run into any danger of people thinking that I am ust being silly, as there is a reasonable explaiation for why I say I feel like a rabbit, whatever reason they believe. [20:46] Going by the indirect truth works for me, but it may not be the best for most. [20:46] I don't know if I have been entirely clear. [20:47] Anyone else want to speak on this topic? [20:47] Yes, TerrorWolf [20:47] We have one more [20:47] ok [20:47] GhiaDon is done? [20:47] Yes. [20:47] Ok [20:47] Lerangfang is next [20:48] * WolfFriend sets mode -v+v GhiaDon Lerangfang [20:48] You are up, Lerangfang [20:48] Afterwards we have open discussion [20:48] thnx [20:48] I do agree with the opinion that you shoudnt involve the community, as also giving people the gist of the topic [20:49] fortunately I had the messed situation of telling my friends when I had my first dream shift [20:49] * Stealth (StealthSha@B76D0E6F.1622617C.5B1E2302.IP) has joined #stdc [20:49] I told them of my dream shift...believing I was a werewolf... [20:50] obviously i know more now. [20:50] Though I don't think I'll tell my family. One reason is I fear their reaction. [20:51] and plus I like to keep this private in a way. I'm more open to my friends weirdly. [20:51] But telling people is never easy for sure. Unfortunately a lot of people have to tell someone, wheter it be their most trusting friend, or the goth that they tlak with occasionally in class. [20:52] Of course, like other personal things, it never is easy telling anybody any personal things. [20:52] I guess the only thing you can do is work up the courage and the second you're about to back out, just tell them. [20:53] I guess thats all you can do. It never is easy. [20:53] And that's my thoughts. [20:53] Thank you [20:53] We will now open up for open discussion [20:53] * WolfFriend sets mode -v Lerangfang [20:53] * WolfFriend sets mode -m [20:53] GhiaDon: may a grill you for a moment? [20:53] I have to say, Wolffriend struck a very important point [20:54] :) [20:54] Bearcat: Sure. [20:54] TigerAcolyte: that he did. [20:54] for those of you who told those close to you about your therianthropy, have you ever gotten an unfavorable response? of the peple I know, they think less ofthose who make some comfession through electronic means than in person. [20:54] GhiaDon: what is 3 + 2? [20:54] :o [20:54] * Elidolente (Guest11@WS239FFA-5E4ED545.sttlwa.fios.verizon.net) has joined #stdc [20:54] My friend still thinks im a werewolf even after I explained her Theriantropy? [20:54] explained to her* [20:54] Hi, Elidolente. You just missed the "coming out' topic. The 2nd one will be last. [20:54] Loki: the first question my mother asked me was "are you sexually attracted to cats?" I thought about it and said "no." [20:55] Mentioning specific terms of the community will increase the chances of the person shutting your words out [20:55] Bearcat: Why are you asking me that? I don't know what you are trying to do. Answer is five, in anycase... [20:55] Branding you "identity crisis" or some other silly thing [20:55] * Loki laughs. [20:55] GhiaDon: ah ha!! You are no rabbit. Rabbits can only count to 4. :"P [20:55] Loki: I explained therianthropy to one of the two friends who I thought would be accepting and he said he thought it couldn't happen and wasn't real. I was very disappointed. [20:55] And thats the fear a lot of people sadly have. of being shut out [20:55] Bearcat: You and your jokes :P [20:55] that's not entirely what I meant, but it's certainly an unfavorable response, Bearcat. xD [20:55] The internet has a "Don't believe it, don't trust it" stigma the older generations generally won't look beyond, in my experience [20:56] mm [20:56] How unfortunate, Amourosa. [20:56] GhiaDon: if you have not read "Watership Down", i emplore you, do so. Also, Tales from Watership down (it's sequel is very good too) [20:56] When I told my parents about the community, they (well, they have a thing about people on the internet anyway) said "be careful about crazies" more or less. I can only wonder how they would have reacted if I mentioned the community first. [20:56] Amourosa: Well ya told them. Thats about all you should do if they arent open to the idea. [20:56] And though they do trust my judgement, that's how they see the internet. [20:57] Loki: well, i in retrospect i wish i had said "pussy, or cats mother?" [20:57] >_> [20:57] I'm sorry, Amourosa [20:57] Bearcat: I have read it, a long time ago, and seen the film, but I wasn't aware of a sequel. [20:57] I can certainly realte to that, WolfFriend, yes. [20:57] Lerangfang: Yeah, I know. It was just really deflating to my hopes that this guy would say it couldn't be real. I didn't tell him about me, I just asked him about therianthropy [20:57] you can trust the internet? ;) [20:57] * WolfFriend nods at Loki [20:57] geek: :o [20:57] that would haev been hilarious, Bearcat. [20:57] GhiaDon: it's a collecton of short stories. [20:58] I have red the sequel to Watership Down. it's very good. [20:58] Bearcat: that would have been so funny! [20:58] WolfFriend: you know my story, found ww.com. took a week, and decided working things out online wasn't for me ;) [20:58] * Shonsu yawns [20:58] amourosa: what exactly did you till your friend? [20:58] Yup, geek [20:58] Loki: thing was, i thought about it seriously before answering. I mean if i have a feline brain why would i not be? But i'm not a normal cat anyhow. [20:58] Amourosa: And thats the fear. If you tell another person make sure you tell someone that's really open to ideas. [20:58] and did you cite the online therianthropic community? [20:58] hmm [20:59] Bearcat: I would have had to do the same thing. I don't find that odd. [20:59] Amourosa: wether it is real to them does not matter. It is real to you. However, it still hurts to have your reality rejected. [20:59] yes it is [20:59] Elidolente: I told him I'd been doing some spiritual research and ran across this term. I didn't cite any online community because I didn't know if he was open to the idea. I explained the terms "therianthropy" and "therian" and asked what he thought about it. This was all done in facebook chat, by the way. [20:59] * J (J@WS239FFA-C67A325B.nycap.res.rr.com) Quit (Quit: ~ Trillian Astra - www.trillian.im ~) [21:00] Bearcat: Well, maybe its cause my family is *really* concervative, and they don't even understand the geek subculture, but i don't expect them to ever understand things, [21:00] Bearcat: no kidding, I felt like he was rejecting me personally. Like he was telling me, "You can't exist like this, it's not real for you." And he's so open-minded, I was completely blindsided by it [21:00] Amourosa: I'm sorry it didn't go well. [21:00] low expections = hard to be dissapointed ;) [21:00] hmm, well the guy just seems a bit close minded, [21:00] * Nessbeast (Nessbeast@WS239FFA-C05AE068.bltmmd.fios.verizon.net) Quit (Ping timeout) [21:00] * J (J@WS239FFA-C67A325B.nycap.res.rr.com) has joined #stdc [21:01] i think the point needs to be made that in general this community *weresource, crossroads, werelist and awareness forums) are all places designed for introspection, challenging each other and to have a place where we feel safe doing so. I don't even like telling people about the community when i'm not sure what their reaction is gonna be. If someone is beligerant with me about my thereianthopy i will keep them away from here. [21:01] mm [21:01] * Shonsu nods [21:01] * graylocke (graylocke@WS239FFA-10347DF9.static.internode.on.net) has joined #stdc [21:02] Amourosa: my father was like that for most of my life. [21:02] I wonder if exposing some one to a community when they're obviously not willing to believe it exists would alter their opinion, or just make it worse. [21:02] Bearcat: And I think thats what should be done. Discretion is required for something like that. I mean if you go out and tell a random person about any of these sites and he has the wrong intensions, it could be really damaging to a person who knows they allowed this. [21:02] * graylocke (graylocke@WS239FFA-10347DF9.static.internode.on.net) has left #stdc [21:03] Lerangfang: truth. We have alot of 'pups' and 'kittens' here too [21:03] mew [21:03] Lerangfang: let's not even get into the damned trolls [21:03] Stealth: ha! [21:03] heheh [21:03] which am I, I wonder [21:03] Bearcat: I eat forum trolls for breakfast. [21:03] Bearcat: and the ones who think WTA/WTF is a manual for being a therian ;) [21:03] Lerangfang: do they stay crunch in milk? [21:04] Lerangfang, then I hope that you can keep their population down. :P [21:04] geek: truth. [21:04] *crunchy [21:04] Bearcat: Yes but they are really fattening. I need to go on a diet lol [21:04] granted (and no offence meant in general) but there's worse in the otherkin community tho ;p [21:04] It's true... [21:04] In one minute we will be going to final discussion [21:05] * geek notes i've been there ;p [21:05] I was on otherkin.net before I came across werelist [21:05] yay. the topic on defenitions and jeopardy [21:06] Ok, we will be heading to the final topic. [21:06] * WolfFriend sets mode +m [21:06] The last topic for tonight is: [21:06] Lots of discussion in the therian community tends to focus on the definition of therianthropy; on what it is. As a result of this, we have many different terms come to mean different "forms" that therianthropy can take, as well as an abundance of terms for various shifting types and lots of other experiences. Are we getting too carried away? Are we over defining the therianthropic experience? Is this creating more confusion and limiting us? Should we [21:06] try to be more generalized? [21:06] * Kumiho (cd8568d1@WS239FFA-2C33FAE9.mibbit.com) Quit (Quit: http://www.mibbit.com ajax IRC Client) [21:06] Lerangfang is up first [21:06] * WolfFriend sets mode +v Lerangfang [21:06] * Nessbeast (Nessbeast@WS239FFA-C05AE068.bltmmd.fios.verizon.net) has joined #stdc [21:06] thanks [21:07] The Term Therianthropy defenately has been highly broaded out in the community. [21:07] And even the word Shifting. It is so broaded out that I still don't understand all of the kinds of "shifts" out there. [21:08] I mean we got P-shifting. We got Mental Shifting [21:08] We got Dream Shifting, Astral Shifting, and probably more kinds of shifts I dont even know off the top of my head. [21:08] Queue: TigerAcolyte, GhiaDon [21:09] I know a lot of people feel the need to spread things out so that Therianthropy becomes one big umbrella topic... but sheesh I think it's a bit overboard. [21:09] And that is my opinion. [21:09] Im done. [21:09] Ok, thank you :) [21:10] * WolfFriend sets mode -v+v Lerangfang TigerAcolyte [21:10] Simply put, what we have defined now is just fine. If the definition of therianthropy is too generalized, [21:10] it becomes harder for a person to confirm if what they're going through is in fact of the same ilk as what most other "Therians" are going through. [21:11] As such it would make it harder for "True" therians to find one another than it is now. [21:11] Queue: GhiaDon, Amourosa [21:11] * Tobisaurus (meow@WS239FFA-3908F2E4.cvx1-c.lee.dial.ntli.net) Quit (Ping timeout) [21:11] However, if we become too well defined, a similar problem arises. [21:11] Queue: GhiaDon, TerrorWolf, Amourosa [21:12] A small handful fit the definition, and only a few of the many "true" therians are able to find each other for edifying conversation. [21:12] Actually, the problem is more severe because you've excluded not only the "could be" therians, but a majority of the "I am" therians as well. [21:12] There is no narrowed-down pool from which to sift through. [21:12] * Eavna (Owner@WS239FFA-7114F75D.sttlwa.dsl-w.verizon.net) has joined #stdc [21:13] An analogy would be sifting a rock-rich sandbox for pebbles as opposed to find a small collection of pebbles in the desert, then having to find the [21:13] rest on your own. [21:13] Defining the different types of shifts, [21:13] However, is another matter. [21:14] I believe that definitions of the different kinds of shifting would be best suplimented by [21:14] a handful of brief, quality "true story" examples of each. This would help aleviate confusion on some of the less common types of shifts like [21:14] aural or astral. [21:15] In short, keep it inbetween defined and generalized. This will allow for natural variance in personal experiences between individuals while still keeping the [21:15] variance from convincing the "I've mistaken therianthropy for another issue of mine" people that they are a therian. [21:15] *Cuts thoughts off* [21:15] I am done [21:16] Thank you [21:16] GhiaDon is next [21:16] * WolfFriend sets mode -v+v TigerAcolyte GhiaDon [21:16] Queue: TerrorWolf, Amourosa [21:18] Personally, I do not find the number of definitions to be a problem, they have become defined because a number of people have experienced them (from my understanding). As long as people are being entirely and completely honest with themselves, and they actually experience something that is a defined term, there is no problem. [21:19] The purpose of a label or term is to save confusion and endless explaination. What are "true" therians? Can "true" therians only experience a specific list of experiences, and anyone who experiences otherwise is obviously false/deluded? [21:21] The list of terms and recognized experiences may continue to grow, if there is anything that has yet to be defined, as the community, from my understanding, is still young. [21:23] People will have different experiences, and to have a definition or article to point torwards for explaination is helpful. However, it is not to be a checklist, not everyone is going to experience everything. [21:24] The only problem I can see arise from having different definitions is if the variety expands too far out of therianthropy, and into something else that may be closer to something else. [21:26] But for the most part, identifying and detailing experiences does more good than bad, as long as people only use it as a dictionary/encyclopedia, and not a list of things to strive for. [21:26] I am done. [21:26] Thanks. [21:26] Next up is TerrorWolf [21:26] * WolfFriend sets mode -v+v GhiaDon TerrorWolf [21:26] :) [21:26] Queue: Amourosa [21:26] Hey gang [21:27] I brought this topic up just to see what people's thoughts on it were, and I am glad to see others agre. [21:27] To me, therianthropy is about how the individual feels, not an agreed upon set of terms or definitions. [21:27] * geek (geek@WS239FFA-C1C91D0.delta16.maxonline.com.sg) Quit (Client exited) [21:27] As a group we try to break everything down into a species, then a sub-species, then a tertiary then quanternary level [21:28] For what? To confuse new people with terms? To confuse people who have been around with a term that means has the most minor distinction between another long felt term? [21:29] We rely on definitions to explain ourselves as a group, when that takes away from the individual aspects of therianthropy. I for one love how you explain your experience in your own words, not in the term that some 'grey muzzle' brought up long ago that has for [21:29] some unknown reason caught on. [21:30] * Tobisaurus (meow@WS239FFA-3908F2E4.cvx1-c.lee.dial.ntli.net) has joined #stdc [21:30] It is partially because of the faux-intellectualism that we have had in the past few years that we now have a term for every shifting type under the sun -- We have became more exclusionary because of it when we should be welcoming new people and letting them explain themselves to us. [21:30] * TerrorWolf sets mode +su [21:30] * TerrorWolf sets mode -su [21:30] * TerrorWolf sets mode +v Amourosa [21:30] Thanks! [21:30] Thanks TerrorWolf [21:30] The problem with therianthropy in general is that itbs multinational and multilingual, as well as a subjective experience. There are some terms we can define pretty surely (like shifting), but youbve got all kinds of therians. [21:30] :) [21:30] Can I go? [21:30] You're up [21:30] :) [21:31] The problem with therianthropy in general is that itbs multinational and multilingual, as well as a subjective experience. There are some terms we can define pretty surely (like shifting), but youbve got all kinds of therians. [21:31] Contherians, suntherians (which, I know, are the same as contherians, but the term is still out there), wolf therians, earwig therians, then you have therians with massive shifts and therians with little or no shifts. But theybre all therian, so that term has to be broad and subject to interpretation. [21:31] * WolfFriend sets mode -v TerrorWolf [21:31] It would be helpful if we could have a set of terms and then ways people can test whether or not they apply to them. A bDo I m-shift? Well, herebs what to look for,b kind of thing. People should rely more on themselves and their personal answers than what the community says. The terms are there to describe an already-occurring event, not help you create somet [21:31] grr [21:31] create something in your mind that could pass for that term. If some new and undefined experience comes to the communitybs attention, a term should, by all means, be made for it. Ibm not saying there should be a maximum, Ibm just saying that some have to be broad and subject to interpretation and some need to be taken out due to overlap with another term. [21:32] Note: this was not directed towards anyone in particular [21:32] Done! [21:32] Anyone else? [21:32] Victory points for fastest many-word post [21:32] * TerrorWolf sets mode -m [21:32] Free discussion time! [21:32] aww! [21:32] Thank you Amourosa [21:32] :D [21:32] :) [21:33] :) [21:33] but i paid already! [21:33] I have to thank GhiaDon for pointing out a mistake I made [21:33] Yay, free discussion [21:33] By "True" Therians, a bad way to put it, I was actually referring to "I am" Therians [21:33] It's all good - I did not mean anything mean by it. [21:33] TigerAcolyte: What do you mean by "I am" therians [21:34] * Elidolente (Guest11@WS239FFA-5E4ED545.sttlwa.fios.verizon.net) Quit (Quit: Elidolente) [21:34] Amourosa: You know, someone should actually do that, make a test or something to give releavnce to if you think ur a terian or not. [21:34] For the rest of what I said myself, I am prepared to defend it. [21:34] Those that are confident and know for sure that they are Therians in the commonly accepted sense [21:34] Even beyond that [21:34] They know, for themselves alone, who/what they are [21:34] therianthropy is too personal to subject to a test. [21:35] Tiger: but do you mean they haven't put any research into it? [21:35] and such a test could be easily abused [21:35] agreed [21:35] True. [21:35] I think it would be difficult to create a diagnostic for something like therianthropy (unless we have a massive psychological-stype study on us as a group) [21:35] Therianthropy Test=Bad Idea [21:35] No. Research would have to be done [21:35] But it's not something that we can do, and is usually frowned upon [21:35] Only you can decide of you are a therianthrope or not. [21:35] Because then people would use the test as an excuse to not think about what they are [21:35] * SerpentineZebra (Serpentine@WS239FFA-4AC6B7CA.washdc.east.verizon.net) Quit (Quit: SerpentineZebra) [21:35] Tiger: Okay, thought so, thanks! [21:35] At least on the theriotype they believe themselves to be [21:36] Which is in general, highly encouraged [21:36] there are no easy answers. [21:36] only easy questions [21:36] true [21:36] About the test: that's why I think it should still be kind of an umbrella term, open for interpretation, but it still has limits [21:36] It is very difficult to have something open and have limits. [21:37] then it should be very basic questions that you could really think like" wow, other people have this going on in their lives too." [21:37] Uncle sam: "You're free americans!" "But! You can't do this, this, this and this" [21:37] not something far out like astral shifting [21:37] Not to be political [21:38] Just an analogy [21:38] TigerAcolyte: Ha! [21:38] so was that the last topic I presume? [21:38] Therianthropy is a personal thing, you can really only limit it by its eytmology [21:38] hmmm [21:39] Right. You've got therians who say they shift X amount of times in 6 different shifting types and they have all the personality traits yada yada yada, then you've got a therian like me who, sometimes, doesn't feel anything therian-ish and has to remember she has always felt this way and doesn't shift or have any special experiences [21:39] Lerangfang, it was the last topic. [21:39] A list of defined terms are not absolute limitations. [21:39] I think that's the most productive discussion I've ever had about Therianthropy [21:39] it was interesting...and I gotta say Tiger defenately had me beat if this was a debate. [21:39] TigerAcolyte, cool :) [21:39] So, I'd totally fail a detailed Are You a Therian? test, even though I'm (pretty sure) a therian [21:39] interesting Amourosa [21:39] I love these chats! [21:39] Lerangfang :) [21:39] :D [21:40] I would fail a test as well [21:40] lol I have to say it. [21:40] i would win :"P [21:40] Pff, you're a cat, Bearcat. You can't help but think that. :P [21:40] ...I just love explaining things in a semi-formal manner [21:40] I mean I know that we do need all these terms and such BUT we should defenately categorize them better. [21:40] <.< O [21:40] How? [21:40] Our collection of terminologies has sort of haphazardly occurred [21:40] I'd fail a pretty detail'd Are You therian test, most likely. [21:40] Shonsu: one of my reasons I believe therianthropy has a psychological aspect to it is because I've had a lot of psychological ailments but only one has been severe and permanent, the others were mild-ish and fleeting [21:41] We make up something and throw it in the basket [21:41] Se here is my basic definition of therianthropy [21:41] And so we get lots of very similar terms, and lots of different ones [21:41] exactly. [21:41] ugh, i need a shower...bbiab [21:41] One who identifies with animals to the point they feel a deep connection that makes its presence known. [21:41] * Shonsu has made his therianthropy up [21:41] I disagree. [21:41] I say we need to at least look at them closer and rethink Shifting in general. [21:41] TerrorWolf: that would include animal totems [21:41] Shonsu: That is your opinion so far. But don't let doubt define you either :) [21:41] because to new guys it can be a bit confusing [21:41] Also, I had my thoughts written out in advance. I think we'd be even if you had that opportunity as well, lerangfang [21:42] true lol [21:42] Amourosa: So what? [21:42] The terms we have now have many people experiencing them, that is how they have become defined (as far as I understand) [21:42] But at the same time, we have so many sites categorizing them all into 4-6 different shifts [21:42] TerrorWolf: so the term "therian" should include anyone who has an animal spirit guide or totem? [21:42] with no real solid, yet to the point, description of it [21:43] my definition is "a core part of my being is a non-human animal." [21:43] Amourosa: I mean in all honesty it should because that is what it really comes from. [21:43] Bearcat: See this is me being a patent examiner ;) [21:43] But your definition just percludes every multi-species therian ;) [21:43] Terrorwolf: very true. [21:43] TerrorWolf: I'm lost now, therianthropy comes from having a spirit guide? [21:43] lol [21:43] Amourosa: It has roots in it [21:44] But then there are those of use who do not have spirit guides...? [21:44] TerrorWolf: how? Where did you get the evidence for that. *intensely curious now* [21:44] GhiaDon: And how are they not therians? [21:44] Terrorwolf: Roots yes, but not every therian has a notable spirit guide. It should be handled a bit differently, more like "this is something to do later in life to delve farther [21:44] Amourosa: Show me evidence that says the opposite. [21:44] into your therianthropy" [21:44] I never said every therian ha a spirit guide [21:44] I know [21:44] Terrorwolf: i did not say that more parts of me could not be different non-human animals :"P [21:45] * Eavna (Owner@WS239FFA-7114F75D.sttlwa.dsl-w.verizon.net) has left #stdc [21:45] Bearcat: You percluded it based on your word choice. 112(2) says you fail. [21:45] I would say partition therianthropy into two sub-catagories, but a point about how much of a folly that would be says no [21:45] Terrorwolf, you made an assumption fail. [21:45] TerrorWolf: then the term seems to be way to broad, are we talking about people who identify internally as animals or people who have spirit guides? To put both and have them be possibly exclusive is to create a very confusing term [21:45] Terrorwolf: I think I may be confused. If therianthropy has roots in spirit quides, and those of us who do not have them, we have no roots? [21:45] but now i'm scampering off to shower. [21:45] Amourosa: Thats not too broad [21:45] TerrorWolf, I would say I *am* a husky, not that husky is any particular spirit guide [21:46] GhiaDon: The eytmology does [21:46] I am, always was, and always will be a husky [21:46] Amen, WolfFriend [21:46] That does not mean the term must [21:46] Or, perhaps even better, a human endowed with husky traits. [21:46] :) [21:46] This si the point I make of trying to recategorize Shifting, and even Therianthropy. Its too confusing and jumbled with other ideas that happen to be "related" to it. [21:46] Terrorwolf: Ah, I was confused. [21:46] But the fact that is where the word gets its basis FROM means something [21:47] Therianthropy covering animalistic beliefs in general is not too broad for that singular reason [21:47] This is about the experience [21:47] Not the word [21:47] Or it could mean nothing. Language is ever-evolving, and words are kidnapped all the time for other uses. [21:47] That is what separates us from furries [21:47] GhiaDon: This is true [21:47] TerrorWolf: but the current definition is what matters at the moment, the etymology means nothing if it no longer applies to the meaning [21:47] Another good point, TerrorWolf [21:47] Amourosa: Are you missing the POINT of this convo?! [21:47] * WolfFriend sets mode -v Amourosa [21:47] O.O [21:47] This is all about how the current definition fails. [21:47] ...meep [21:47] Sorry, forgot that Amourosa was still voiced :P [21:48] And how the species of it fail. [21:48] What did I do??? [21:48] Continue :P [21:48] You did nothing, Amourosa [21:48] They feel to consider the individual [21:48] They link to the group which is never good [21:48] Voice means nothing unless this place is +m [21:48] Which it is not :P [21:48] TerrorWolf: we are arguing about to different things, this isn't going to go anywhere [21:48] *two [21:48] my bad [21:48] anyway im going guys. nice chatting with ya. [21:48] later [21:48] too late for me. [21:48] Night [21:48] Bye bye! [21:48] Amourosa: How so? [21:48] * Lerangfang (Lerangfang@WS239FFA-5A8DD3B4.eastlink.ca) Quit (Quit: Lerangfang) [21:49] TerrorWolf: As I see it, you are talking about the experience and I am talking about definition. [21:49] * moonwolf (moonwolf@WS239FFA-65405AC0.dyn.centurytel.net) Quit (Quit: moonwolf) [21:49] The experience is a subjective event, unique to the individual [21:49] The experience is what should make the definition -- That was the entire pointof my conversation [21:49] The definition is something for everyone to reference [21:49] I would say that the experiences should be a basis around which a definition is made, not the idea. [21:49] There really should be no definition [21:49] It should only be the experience really. [21:49] Then there is no language [21:50] Ha, yes, what TerrorWolf said [21:50] That I can agree with. [21:50] Amourosa: There is not a need for there to be one. [21:50] We do not need our own lexicon. [21:50] We use these terms as crutches I think. [21:50] We're on different levels [21:51] We can't operate with Plato's forms [21:51] alone [21:51] We need words and language to interact effectively. [21:51] But then we get into the issue of "Are you talking about totemic experiences or animal soul experiences?" If that makes sense [21:51] words and languages, at best, are ill-fitting attempts to convey larger concepts and ideas. [21:52] TigerAcolyte: As long as the individual can explain it, should it matter? [21:52] No [21:52] TerrorWolf: if you're going to put both experiences under one term, it would get pretty confusing [21:52] But why should a person be obligated to have a long discussion explaining when so many people experience the same thing? [21:52] Amourosa: You seriously seem to be missing the point of what we are getting at here. [21:52] GhiaDon: Most people do not [21:53] But it's nice to let the other end know just what direction you're coming from [21:53] Rarely will your experiences direct correlate to someone elses. [21:53] TerrorWolf: then please lay it out for me in several sentences [21:53] Amourosa: What we are discussing here is how the experiences should control, not the terms and definitions set out. [21:54] Experiences control what? [21:54] Don't growl at me. [21:54] Within a term, many people may experience the same thing. That is why we have different terms, because many people do not experience the same things. A large number of people experience something very similiar, there is a term, a large number of people experience another thing, there is a term. [21:54] GhiaDon: We have too many [21:54] * graylocke (graylocke@WS239FFA-10347DF9.static.internode.on.net) has joined #stdc [21:54] * graylocke (graylocke@WS239FFA-10347DF9.static.internode.on.net) has left #stdc [21:54] And frankly, most of those people who experience the 'term' do not experience the exact nature of the term. [21:55] terms are useful, but they have their limits. D: [21:55] As such, the term technically fails to explain their experience. [21:55] I suspect some excess terms will fall by the wayside. [21:55] The atmosphere is getting a bit too tense for my taste. I think I'll sit this one out and observe the outcome [21:55] We have overstressed the terms [21:55] They are crutches. [21:55] Buffalo: They have not [21:55] for instance, I do not actually fit any therianthropic terms. however, I consider myself a therian, and i mooooostly fit a lot of them. [21:55] If they are no longer wanted they will no longer be used. [21:55] Ther is no need to have an exact, there is variance under the terms. [21:55] GhiaDon: We do not need the terms if we explain it. [21:55] TerrorWolf: there can be no "exact nature" of the term because people take them different ways [21:55] Which would you feel more comfortable with [21:55] Many people experience the same thing, not a lot of people experience the exact same thing. [21:55] If they have not fallen by the wayside they must be useful to someone. [21:56] Someone who says "I experience mental shifts" versus "I regularly experience shifts where I am unable to control myself, where I feel as though I am living outside of myself but yet still there. During this time I can feel my therioside control my every move and whim." [21:56] Mental shifts [21:56] Buffalo: They are usually redundant. [21:56] Amourosa: Why? [21:57] TerrorWolf: because having to sit and write out that whole phrase over and over would really be aggravating and I'd make a term for it if one didn't already exist [21:57] Also [21:57] But explaining yourself over and over is also redundant. [21:57] GhiaDon: Yes but in the end percision is better. [21:57] Buffalo: Then you get similar terms competing. For instance, one person insists on saying "Pop" and another one insists on saying "Soda". What happens when they meet? They get in an arguement [21:57] Because I know that others experience this, and having a term to share in common with them brings a feeling of similarity and I'm-not-alone [21:58] It helps you as an individual to learn. [21:58] Amourosa: Thats a problem though [21:58] It encourages people to term-fit. [21:58] We see it a lot with new people. [21:58] It is better to have a specific explaination, possibly with someone who is unfamiliar with your own personal experiences. [21:58] They latch on to a definition and do not let go, even though after a while they learn it does not fit them at all. [21:58] TerrorWolf: but they have to be able to self-define it before matching their definition to a pre-existing term [21:58] TW you are unlikely to be able to arbitrate dropping one term, or even reaching a consensus. But for some of us those little differences are interesting. [21:58] When if they listed their experiences outright, they would have learned that 'hey, I am wrong with this fitting me'. [21:58] But to have later discussions with the same people, it is redundant to use it over and over. [21:59] Buffalo: If you explain your differences, tahts better than forcing yourself as a square peg into a round hole. [21:59] TerrorWolf: then that is a cultural thing and needs to be changed [21:59] Amourosa: Too bad its self perpetual. [21:59] The terms themselves are highly useful when used correctly [22:00] Amourosa: How many terms do you know the definitions to? [22:00] It might be ideal to first figure out what you are, then discuss with people, then abbreviate to a term. [22:00] It is 10 PM EST. I believe my time is up [22:00] TerrorWolf: not necessarily. A therianthropy forum is a controlled environment where such changes could be instigated and influenced [22:00] Terrorwolf: in the whole English language? [22:00] Amourosa: Too bad some people lurk forums. [22:00] Amourosa: No community-wise. [22:00] Thank you all for a wonderful discussion. I had an enjoyable experience, and I hope to have another on the next meet [22:00] later TigerAcolyte [22:01] * TigerAcolyte (443dc1a5@WS239FFA-2C33FAE9.mibbit.com) Quit (Quit: http://www.mibbit.com ajax IRC Client) [22:01] I would love for us to at a minimal severly cut down the number of definitions [22:01] TerrorWolf: What do you mean "too bad people lurk"? I didn't say you needed to interact for this to work. [22:01] There was a period where they were popping up constnatly. [22:01] I do think there are too many [22:01] Bedtime for this fox, have a good night [22:02] So if we can all at least agree that we have WAY too many definitions and terms [22:02] * J (J@WS239FFA-C67A325B.nycap.res.rr.com) Quit (Quit: ~ Trillian Astra - www.trillian.im ~) [22:02] Thats at least a good point to agree upon. [22:02] :) [22:02] I'm a lurker, and one of the things first hand that turns me off is the ammount of definitions and hairsplitting that goes on. <.< just saying. [22:02] have a good night all [22:02] * TerrorWolf (rmr236@core.weresource.org) has left #stdc [22:02] Good night! [22:02] "Night. [22:02] Nessbeast: hear hear [22:02] or here here [22:02] Whatever it is [22:02] :P [22:03] Goodnight to all others about to leave before I can wish them a good night. [22:03] 'Night! [22:03] Night [22:03] :) [22:03] * Amourosa (81dbbfb1@WS239FFA-2C33FAE9.mibbit.com) Quit (Quit: http://www.mibbit.com ajax IRC Client) [22:04] * Nessbeast (Nessbeast@WS239FFA-C05AE068.bltmmd.fios.verizon.net) has left #stdc